VPN & blocking

Quad9's Exit From France: Why Cloudflare Is Sounding the Alarm

Cloudflare and Mullvad on Quad9 leaving France: what the court demanded, who is hit when DNS fails, and what awaits Cloudflare, Google and Cisco in Belgium.

Cloudflare has published a post on Quad9 leaving France, titled “A canary in the coal mine.” The Swiss non-profit foundation Quad9 is pulling its free public DNS resolver 9.9.9.9 out of the country after a French court ruling. The court imposed daily penalties for the service’s failure to block domains tied to alleged copyright infringement.

Mullvad adds that the list of domains was compiled by a French government agency at the request of a Qatari TV company, and the court requires Quad9 to stop returning correct IP addresses for them. Mullvad argues this creates a system of censorship in which the French government and anyone who has its ear can censor any domain. According to Cloudflare, Quad9’s resolver in France is used by government bodies, universities, hospitals and utilities. The foundation does not know who its users are and cannot warn them, so those who do not switch resolvers will lose their internet with no explanation. Devices such as security systems and thermostats with 9.9.9.9 hardwired are the hardest case. Mullvad Browser users in France who picked Quad9 for DNS over HTTPS will need to change their settings.

Cloudflare acknowledges that rightsholders have a legitimate interest in fighting piracy, but calls blocking through public resolvers ineffective. In its words, it can be bypassed in under a minute by switching resolvers, and anyone who knows a site’s IP address does not need a resolver at all. A resolver blocks a whole domain rather than a single file, and the user gets no explanation why a site fails to load. The company cites a study finding that most online piracy in Europe is hosted in Europe and argues takedowns should be demanded from hosting providers.

A similar fight is under way in Belgium. A Belgian court has ordered Cloudflare, Google and Cisco to start blocking sites through their public resolvers by early January 2027 or face substantial penalties. Cloudflare, together with Google and Cisco, has appealed and hopes for a ruling before the end of the year. There are precedents: Cisco earlier withdrew its OpenDNS resolver from France, Portugal and, temporarily, Belgium, while German courts several years ago rejected requests to force Cloudflare and Quad9 to block via DNS.

Quad9 has operated since 2017, launched with the involvement of IBM, Packet Clearing House and the Global Cyber Alliance. It stands out for filtering out phishing and malware domains by default. In France, according to Cloudflare, it was a small foundation with a single service and no other means of demonstrating compliance with the order. A French court, by contrast, rejected penalties against Cloudflare for not blocking through 1.1.1.1, finding its measures through the CDN and reverse proxy sufficient. KRAKOBIT earlier reported that Quad9’s resolver in France will shut down on November 24.

Source: Cloudflare Blog