Why Claude and ChatGPT ban accounts: Raketa Pay's review
Raketa Pay, a foreign subscription payment service, reviews theories behind Claude and ChatGPT blocks: VPN, language, IP, card. What is checked, what is not.
Raketa Pay, a service for paying for foreign subscriptions, has published an analysis on Habr of why accounts get blocked in Claude and ChatGPT. The authors argue that many “known rules” of a ban remain assumptions that get passed off as established facts when retold. This is the company’s opinion, not the result of testing the platforms’ internal systems.
The authors work on Raketa Pay’s technical team. By their count, more than 15,000 subscriptions have gone through the service, but they note themselves that this is not 15,000 investigated blocks and not access to the platforms’ internal anti-fraud. The typical story they start from: Claude stops working for a user, a search offers explanations ranging from a VPN and a Russian IP to the Russian language and the bank card, and then comes trial and error with networks, countries and cards. Even when access returns, the cause stays unclear.
The authors take their examples of disputed claims from publications. In their view, a Habr news piece on Anthropic blocks is headlined as if the signs of a ban were already known, while inside it retells a community theory of a points system, and Anthropic does not disclose how violators are detected. An expert quoted by Kommersant FM, they write, refers to company documents that supposedly name Russian-language code comments as one of the criteria, but no specific document is shown. Raketa Pay did not verify those claims. They put the difference this way: “switched VPN and got a warning” describes a sequence of events, while “banned for switching VPN” is already an explanation.
The authors also suggest separating situations that all get called a ban: the site does not open, login triggers an extra check, a card is declined, a subscription is paid but access is restricted, the account is disabled. OpenAI, they say, separately describes a network error with a block message, which on its own does not prove the account has been permanently disabled. The company also says unusual login locations, devices and activity can trigger warnings, and that access from unsupported countries can lead to suspension or blocking. Anthropic has its own supported-regions policy that also takes an organization’s circumstances into account. The authors found no confirmation in the public rules of the formula “wrote in Russian, got banned”.
It is worth noting that Raketa Pay earns money from paying for foreign subscriptions, which is exactly the part of the market where these blocks are discussed. KRAKOBIT has already covered Anthropic’s regional restrictions: what Anthropic changes for companies from Russia from November 12 and who gets banned in Claude after ID checks with a Russian passport.
Source: Хабр, блог Raketa Pay